SGibeaver4444

Don’t Call it a Rally After entering an inning when losing, get 5 hits during that same inning.
(Excludes simulated gameplay)

The Start of Something After entering an inning when losing, get 3 hits during that same inning.
(Excludes simulated gameplay)

Horses in the Pen Set an opening pitcher for a bullpen game in Franchise.

"Wouldn't wanna make things too easy." Get 5 Gold Medals in AR Trials
5/5

Wonderful Toys Purchase all Gadget Upgrades for any single character

"I own the place." Purchase all Batcave Expansions
5/5

"Things have improved." Prevent each type of Crime in Gotham once

"Is that like parachuting?" Glide in 10 different wind tunnels
10/10

Who’s the New Kid? Get a hit against or strikeout any former MLB The Show cover athlete.

"Did He Say Nirvana?" Complete Episode 5: Conflagration.

A Robbery! Rob a home run. (Excludes simulated gameplay)

"We'll Show the World the Hope in Your Rain" Complete Episode 4: Raindrops.

Creature Comforter Deliver a wild animal to the Animal Shelter for the first time. (Animals required to complete orders do not count.)

"Help us Bring Australia into the Network" Complete Episode 3: Drawbridge.

Making It Your Own Use a screenshot taken in Photo Mode to decorate your private room.

You’re Sure They Meant Me? Score a run with a pinch runner that has 26 speed or lower.

Flush While playing Diamond Quest, buy two perks from Coach’s Cart on a single map.

Out of the Shadows Unlock Talia

Up for the Challenge Complete 20 Challenges
20/20

The Strength to Fight Reach Combat Combo of 99 hits

An Endless Winter Complete Chapter Four

Brainiac Unlock all trophies.

Maybe It's the Hair Spy on Bobby's love life.

Wolpaw Says Thanks Hear Vernon's Ghost Story.

Made Man Witness Maloof's transformation.

Holiday Dinner Cook and consume two different kinds of roast in one sitting.

"Gotham can feel a little safer." Prevent 30 Crimes
30/30

A Grayson Graduation Unlock Nightwing

GOAT MODE Get a Hit or Strikeout while playing on GOAT difficulty. (Excludes simulated gameplay)

Baseball is Better Together Play an online or couch co-op game.

I Thought That Was Unbeatable! Complete Meat Circus.

Math is Hard Achieve Rank 101.

Figgy Piggy Gather all Figments.

Happy Bags Sort all Emotional Baggage.

No More Secrets Crack all Vaults.

Cowardly and Superstitious Lot Defeat every type of enemy once

Gone Questing Successfully Complete a Diamond Quest Map Run.

"You either buy a hero…" Purchase 5 Items from Shops
5/5

"You're becoming quite a celebrity." Discover 100 open world events
100/100

"No, sir. The OTHER car." Purchase 3 Vehicles from the Batcave
3/3

"Let's see what Batgirl can do!" Unlock Batgirl

The Dynamic Duo Complete Chapter Three

"It's not exactly a normal world." Visit every District
9/9

"This is my city." Place a Pin on the Map

The Boy Wonder Unlock Robin

"Do I look like I'm joking?" Complete Chapter Two

"Life's been good to me." Collect 1,000,000 Studs

This is My Home Play in a user created stadium.

Are You Still There? Strikeout without swinging the bat during an at-bat.

NLB Historian ’26 Complete Four Negro League Storylines.