RallyCap91

Alone in the Dark All Trophies

I Don’t Got All Night Finish the game in 3 hours or less

Librarian Read all the clues

Radical Acceptance Submit to the Dark Man

Safe and Sound Save New Orleans from the Black Goat

Chatterbox Talk to everybody about everything

What Just Happened? Give Grace a present

Teetotaller Finish the game without drinking from your flask

Nobody Knows What Happened Consider ending it all

I Abandoned Him Own up to your awful past

You Can’t Keep Me Out! Open all of the safes and locks in the game

Look At All the Free Stuff I Got! Find all the lagniappes

Whatever It Takes Kill a monster with an opportunity

One of the Thousand Young Join a cult

Case Closed Save New Orleans from the Black Goat

Back to Normal Break the Pact with the Dark Man

Frenzy Enter hell

The Past as a Present Get what you want

When Therapy Makes It Worse Break through the barriers of self-deceit

I Stole the Child and Let Him Drown Own up to your awful past

Watch Out Where You’re Waving That Thing Aim your gun at a human being

An Honest Day’s Work Play for more than 8 hours

Where I Belong Return to Derceto

Losing My Mind Walk into the desert

Bonfire Night Kill an enemy with fire

Gangster Kill an enemy with Tommy gun

Drop Me Off In New Orleans Escape the Dark Man

Somewhere Else Entirely Find the Convent of Taroella

Found & Lost Talk to Jeremy in the chapel

Hard Boiled Kill an enemy with shotgun

Don’t Mind If I Do Finish a Lagniappe set

Left Holding the Bag Find Jeremy’s bag

The Thin Veneer of Civilization Break through a barrier

On the Mend Put a talisman socket back together

In Between There Are Doors Find your own talisman

Come At Me! Kill a monster with a melee weapon

Now You're On the Trolley! Kill a monster with a ranged weapon

Welcome to Derceto Break into Derceto

Suit Up In Road to the Show, equip a piece of equipment in every slot.

Going Gold Achieve "Gold" in any mini game within Road to the Show.

#1 In Your Heart Get drafted as the #1 overall draft pick in the MLB Draft. (Road to the Show)

Moving Up the Board In Road to the Show, choose to go to college and come out with a higher draft stock than before.

I Don’t Need It In Road to the Show, have 50 Show Tokens in your inventory at once.

Flush While playing Diamond Quest, buy two perks from Coach’s Cart on a single map.

Horses in the Pen Set an opening pitcher for a bullpen game in Franchise.

You’re Sure They Meant Me? Score a run with a pinch runner that has 26 speed or lower.

GOAT MODE Get a Hit or Strikeout while playing on GOAT difficulty. (Excludes simulated gameplay)

Rally Cap After entering an inning when losing, get 7 hits during that same inning. (Excludes simulated gameplay)

Don’t Call it a Rally After entering an inning when losing, get 5 hits during that same inning.
(Excludes simulated gameplay)

NLB Historian ’26 Complete Four Negro League Storylines.